Meanwhile, Facebook was called to task
for not being quick enough to stamp out pages such as "Fly Kicking
Sluts in the Uterus" and "Violently Raping Your Friend Just For Laughs."
Hateful words and actions
targeting women and other groups are, of course, nothing new. But in
our digital age, social media sites must increasingly face the fact that
their services have become the new schoolyard or city square, where a
majority of friendly discussion and positive interaction comes with an
ugly undercurrent of nastiness.
"Expressed hate and abuse
is unfortunately part of our society, and it is now also part of our
real-time digital culture," said Brian Solis, a new media analyst for
Altimeter Group and author of "What's the Future of Business? Changing the Way Businesses Create Experiences."
"As we live the digital
lifestyle, our expectations are such that any menace should not only be
dealt with accordingly, it should be done immediately."
Feminist campaign sparks Twitter attacks
The question for sites
such as Twitter, which on Tuesday responded to a petition to make
reporting abusive behavior easier, is how to police hundreds of millions
of people, providing a safe environment for some users while respecting
the free speech of others.
At the heart of the
problem are the mechanics of policing. The sheer number of users means
that flagging misbehavior is like playing a vast, never-ending game of
Whac-a-Mole.
"Twitter represents a new
medium that the world hasn't seen before," Solis said of the site that
supports 400 million tweets every day. "To protect its users, it must
invest in automated and manual safety and reporting mechanisms as it
grows."
This week, the Bank of England announced that "Pride and Prejudice" author Jane Austen will be featured on 10-pound notes. The move came after a campaign by Caroline Criado-Perez and others.
On Twitter, Criado-Perez
wrote that the response got ugly fast: "I actually can't keep up with
the screen-capping & reporting -- rape threats thick and fast now,"
she wrote now. "If anyone wants to report the tweets to Twitter." Some
of the accounts she cited have since been suspended.
Eventually, one man was arrested Sunday in Manchester, England.
British police also are investigating a threat of rape and murder made to Stella Creasy, a Labour Party member of Parliament, after she tweeted her support of Criado-Perez.
But activists complained that Twitter didn't act quickly enough. A Change.org petition, calling on the site to add a prominent "report abuse" button, had gotten more than 88,000 signatures as of Tuesday.
The effort prompted Del Harvey, Twitter's senior director for Trust & Safety, to respond Tuesday in a blog post titled "We Hear You."
"We see an incredible
amount of activity passing through our systems ...," he wrote on
Twitter's UK blog. "The vast majority of these use cases are positive.
That said, we are not blind to the reality that there will always be
people using Twitter in ways that are abusive and may harm others."
Harvey noted that three
weeks ago the site rolled out a tool for Twitter for iPhone that lets
users report individual tweets. That feature will hit Web and other
mobile systems soon, he wrote.
He acknowledged, however, that putting eyeballs on every offensive tweet is difficult, if not impossible.
"While manually
reviewing every tweet is not possible due to Twitter's global reach and
level of activity, we use both automated and manual systems to evaluate
reports of users potentially violating our Twitter Rules,'
Harvey wrote. "These rules explicitly bar direct, specific threats of
violence against others and use of our service for unlawful purposes,
for which users may be suspended when reported."
The movement, and response, are not unlike a similar recent effort on Facebook.
In May, a coalition of
women's groups called for the site to get tough on pages that appeared
to embrace hate speech, particularly violent language, toward women.
Facebook responded by
rolling out a slate of efforts that, among other things, increased
accountability for pages that post content that is "cruel or
insensitive."
Speaking Saturday at the BlogHer conference
in Chicago, Facebook Chief Operating Officer Sheryl Sandberg
acknowledged the difficulties in policing abusive behavior among the
site's more than 1 billion account holders. But she said tools to do so
continue to improve.
"We have this really big
challenge between free expression, which is really important ..., and
creating a safe and protected community," she said. "We take both very
seriously.
"The No. 1 thing people
can do is when you find content that's inappropriate, there's a report
button. Hit that report button because we can look at and take down
inappropriate content as long as we see it, and (it) is really an
important part of what we're trying to do."
Both the Twitter and
Facebook episodes mark what appears to be a shift in online culture.
Throughout the Web's history, a certain amount of bad behavior has come
to be expected, be it intentionally provocative online trolling or
earnest hatred spewed more freely because of the ability to do so
anonymously.
But, in 2013, it's
become nearly impossible to distinguish where "Web culture" ends and
culture as a whole begins. Solis, the analyst, noted that as social
media become more and more mainstream, bad behavior that would never be
accepted on a sidewalk will increasingly be policed, one way or another,
online.
"The idea of 'freedom of
tweet' does not supersede law," he said. "Expression aimed at hurting
or threatening someone is indeed a threat heard around the world."
0 comments:
Post a Comment